Rediscovering classics: Robert Darnton’s communications circuit

Many scholars point to the crisis in the Russian bibliology. Meanwhile, those involved in the discussion specify the origins of the crisis in the discipline differently. One possible way to overcome the theoretical crisis of bibliology is to turn to Robert Darnton’s conceptual model of communications circuit. Robert Darnton is well known for his studies in the history of book culture of the modern era yet his model, which has long been recognized as a classic in international historical book studies, has been ignored by Russian bibliologists. The author describes the model that contemplates to identify agents of book communications; the sustained interactions between the agents structure and reproduce the world of book culture. The methodological context of the “pragmatic turn” that defines the model-based concept of book culture based on Clifford Geertz’s semiotic theory of culture, is revised. Possible ways of adapting Darnton’s model to the subsequent stages of media development are outlined. The communications circuit model offers research optics to consider book culture as the communicative wholeness within which the book serves as a medium to facilitate social interactions between different agents involved in the book communication process. Application of Darnton’s model would provide a new research agenda and its incorporation into the relevant international scholarly context.

1. Kar`er Zh.-K., E`ko U. Ne nadei`tes` izbavit`sia ot knig! / Interv`iu Zh.-F. de Tonnaka. Sankt-Peterburg : Simpozium, 2013. 336 s.

2. Markova V. A. Razvitie knigovedeniia v kontekste diskursa krizisa // Trudy` SanktPeterburgskogo gosudarstvennogo instituta kul`tury`. T. 217: Kniga i knizhnoe delo v XIX–XXI vv. Sankt-Peterburg, 2018. S. 92–98.

3. Stoliarov Iu. N. Dokumentologiia: prichiny` poiavleniia, e`tapy` razvitiia // Nauchny`e i tekhnicheskie biblioteki. 2021. № 1. S. 15–26.

4. Stoliarov Iu. N. Dokumentologiia: uchebnoe posobie. Oryol : Gorizont, 2013. 370 s.

5. Leezunova I. V., Pavlenko S. V. Transformatciia knigi v usloviiakh medii`ny`kh revoliutcii` // Bibliosfera. 2020. № 1. S. 12–23.

6. Leezunova I. V. Transformatciia knizhnoi` kul`tury` v sotcial`ny`kh kommunikatciiakh XIX–XXI vv. // Sovremenny`e problemy` knizhnoi` kul`tury`: osnovny`e tendentcii i perspektivy` razvitiia: 100 let Inbelkul`tu i belorusskoi` akademicheskoi` nauke. Materialy` Научные и технические библиотеки, 2023, № 11 137 XV Belorussko-Rossii`skogo nauchnogo seminara-konferentcii. Central`naia nauchnaia biblioteka im. Iakuba Kolasa Natcional`noi` akademii nauk Belarusi; FGBUN NITC «Nauka» RAN. Moskva, 2022. S. 283–287.

7. E`l`iashevich D. A. O «renessanse bibliologii», knigovedenii i ne tol`ko // Potentcial biblioteki v sovremennom mire: transformatcii, perspektivy`: materialy` Vserossii`skoi` nauchnoprakticheskoi` konferentcii s mezhdunarodny`m uchastiem. Samara, 2021. S. 117–126.

8. E`l`iashevich D. A. Knigovedenie: zhizn` posle smerti // Trudy` Sankt-Peterburgskogo gosudarstvennogo instituta kul`tury`. 2018. T. 217. S. 55–81.

9. Rubinshtei`n E. B. Robert Darnton: «intellektual`naia istoriia snizu» // Dialog so vremenem: al`manakh intellektual`noi` istorii. Moskva, 1999. Vy`p. 1. S. 266–278.

10. Staf I. K. Istoriia knigi i istoriia literatury`: problemy` vzaimodei`stviia // Trudy` SanktPeterburgskogo gosudarstvennogo instituta kul`tury`. 2018. № 217. S. 99–111.

11. Darnton R. What is the History of Books? Daedalus. 1982. Vol. 111. № 3. Representations and Realities (Summer, 1982). P. 65–83.

12. Volkov V. V., Harhordin O. V. Teoriia praktik. Sankt-Peterburg : Izdatel`stvo Evropei`skogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge, 2008. 298 s.

13. Darnton R. Velikoe koshach`e poboishche i drugie e`pizody` iz istorii frantcuzskoi` kul`tury`. Moskva : Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2002. 384 s.

14. Ortner S. Theory in Anthropology since the Sixties // Comparative Studies in Society and History. 1984. Vol. 26. P. 126–166.

15. Girtc K. Interpretatciia kul`tur. Moskva : Rossii`skaia politicheskaia e`ntciclopediia (ROSSPE`N), 2004. 560 s.

16. Brodel` F. Istoriia i obshchestvenny`e nauki. Istoricheskaia dlitel`nost` // Filosofiia i metodologiia istorii: sbornik statei`. Moskva : Izdatel`stvo «Progress», 1977. S. 114–142.

17. Brodel` F. Sredizemnoe more i sredizemnomorskii` mir v e`pohu Philippa II. Ch. 1. Rol` sredy`. Moskva : Iazy`ki russkoi` kul`tury`, 2002. 496 s.

18. Berk P. Istoricheskaia antropologiia i novaia kul`turnaia istoriia // Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2005. № 5 (75). S. 64–91.

19. Darnton R. Poe`ziia i politciia. Set` kommunikatcii` v Parizhe XVIII veka. Moskva: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2016. 192 s.

20. Ginzburg K. Mify` – e`mblemy` – primety`. Morfologiia i istoriia. Sbornik statei`. Moskva : Novoe izdatel`stvo, 2004. 348 s.

21. Venediktova T. Novosti iz istorii knigi // Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2019. № 5 (159). S. 338–346.

22. Kiriia I. V., Novikova A. A. Istoriia i teoriia media : uchebnik dlia vuzov. Moskva : Izdatel`skii` dom Vy`sshei` shkoly` e`konomiki, 2017. 423 s.

23. Darnton R. «What is the History of Books?» revisited. Modern Intellectual History. 2007. Vol. 4. № 3. P. 495–508.

24. Darnton R. Leeteraturny`i` Tur de Frans: mir knig nakanune Frantcuzskoi` revoliutcii. Moskva : Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2022. 480 s. Scientific and Technical Libraries, 2023, № 11 138

25. Murray P. R., Squires C. The Digital Publishing Communications Circuit // Book 2.0. 2013. Vol. 3. No. 1. P. 3–23. https://doi.org/10.1386/btwo.3.1.3_1

26. Pecoskie J., Hill H. Beyond Traditional Publishing Models: An Examination of the Relationships between Authors, Readers, and Publishers // Journal of Documentation. 2015. Vol. 71. № 3. P. 609–626.

27. Adams T. R., Barker N. A. New Model for the Study of the Book // A Potencie of Life: Books in Society. The Clark lectures, 1986–1987. London : The British Library, 1993. P. 5–44.

28. Van der Weel A. The Communications Circuit Revisited // Jaarboek voor Nederlandse Boekgeschiedenis. 2001. Jaargang 8. P. 13–25.

29. Charest M. Revisions to Darnton's «Communications Circuit». URL: https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/72806263753e4994b1df015ba94d58cd

30. Makarov M. L. Osnovy` teorii diskursa. Moskva : ITDGK «Gnozis», 2003. 280 s.