Appraisal of documentary heritage objects value in scientific library, archives, museum: topical problems of theory and practice
https://doi.org/10.33186/1027-3689-2021-4-93-116
Abstract
The article is devoted to the topical problems of theory and practice of appraisal of documentary heritage objects value in scientific libraries, archives, museums taking into consideration functional and stock specifics of these institutions. Its goals and tasks, principles and axiological criteria are described. It is shown that the main goal of such appraisal is determining the place of documentary heritage objects as the objects of the appraisal in the system of cultural values of modern society, establishing the belonging of these objects to cultural heritage objects of world, national, regional, local significance. Appraisal of documentary heritage objects is analyzed as one of important areas of scientific and administrative activities which to a large extent ensures the functioning, improvement of information potential and accordingly the image of the library, archives, museum. The Ukrainian experience of the recent decades is highlighted in many aspects, namely: regulation, organization and appraising documentary heritage objects at the state, interdepartmental and departmental levels, at the level of the profile institution fund-holder. The features of the appraisal, the objects of which are archival heritage objects and book heritage objects, are revealed. It is emphasized that the appraisal of value of the existing funds and collections of documentary heritage objects is the basis for the development and implementation of modern individual concepts and integrative projects for libraries, archives and museums, which provides for the coexistence and interrelation of material expositions and various forms of virtual information.
About the Author
I. Ya. Losiyevsky
Kharkiv State Academy of Culture
Ukraine
Ukraine
Igor Ya. Losiyevsky – Dr. Sc. (Philology), Assoc. Prof., Professor of the Chair of Information, Library and Archival Business
Kharkiv
References
1. Leontev D. A. Kompleksnaya gumanitarnaya ekspertiza : metodologiya i smysl / Leontev D. A., Ivanchenko G. V. – Moskva : Smysl, 2008. – 135 s.
2. Nesterov A. V. Osnovy ekspertnoy deiatelnosti : ucheb. posobiye / A. V. Nesterov ; Gos. un-t – Vyssh. shkola ekonomiki. – Moskva : Izd. dom Gos. un-ta – Vyssh. shkoly ekonomiki, 2009. – 167 s.
3. Shman S. Yu. Ekspertna dіialnіst : problemy ta perspektyvy / S. Yu. Shman // Vіsn. Prykarpatskogo un-tu. Mystetctvoznavstvo. – Іvano-Frankivsk, 2006. – Vyp. XII–XІІІ. – S. 265–268.
4. Antonenko І. Є. Novі pіdkhody do provedennya ekspertyzy tsіnnostі dokumentіv (zarubіzhnyy dosvіd) / Іryna Antonenko // Arkhіvoznavstvo. Arkheografіya. Dzhereloznavstvo : mіzhvіd. zb. nauk. pr. – Vyp. 9. – [Kyyiv, 2007]. – S. 27–38.
5. Zhukova M. P. Ekspertiza tsennosti dokumentov i komplektovaniye arkhivov : (vchera, segodnia, zavtra) / M. P. Zhukova // Otechestv. arkhivy. – 2004. – № 4. – S. 37–44.
6. Zhumer V. Vazhneishie aspekty ekspertizy tcennosti dokumentov : analiz mezhdunarodnogo opyta (1950–1990-e gg.) / Vladimir Zhumer // Otechestv. arkhivy. – 2000. – № 4. – S. 3–17.
7. Selіverstova K. T. Ekspertyza tsіnnostі dokumentіv : utochnennya poniattya ta yogo zmіstu / Kateryna Selіverstova // Studіi z arkh. spravy ta dokumentoznavstva. – T. 17. – Kyyiv, 2009. – S. 73–82.
8. Selchenkova S. V. Ekspertyza tsіnnostі upravlіnskykh dokumentіv : іstorіya, teorіya, metodyka : nauk.-metod. posіb. / S. Selchenkova, K. Selіverstova ; Derzh. arkh. sluzhba Ukrayiny, Ukr. NDІ arkh. spravy ta dokumentoznavstva, Spіlka arkhіvіstіv Ukraini. – Kyyiv ; Rіvne, 2011. – 169 s.
9. Teoriya i praktika ekspertizy tcennosti dokumentov i komplektovaniya gosudarstvennykh arkhivov SSSR / Vsesoiuz. nauch.-issled. in-t dokumentovedeniya i arkh. dela. – Tr. VNIIDAD. – Moskva, 1974. – T. 4, ch. 1–2. – 556 s.
10. Boles F. Archival Appraisal / Frank Boles, Julia Marks Young. – N. Y. ; L. : Neal-Schuman Publishers, 1991. – 118 p.
11. Craig B. L. Archival appraisal : theory and practice / Barbara Lazenby Craig. – Münich : K. G. Saur, 2004. – 224 p.
12. Ham F. G. Selecting and Appraising Archives and Manuscripts / F. Gerald Ham. – Chicago : Society of American Archivists, 1993. – 106 p.
13. Harisson H. P. The Archival Appraisal of Sound Recording and Related Materials / Helen P. Harisson. – Paris : UNESCO, 1987. – 86 p.
14. Heywood H. M. Appraising Legal Value in Records / Heather Mary Heywood. – [Vancouver, B. C.] : University of British Columbia, 1991. – 166 p.
15. Kula S. The Archival Appraisal of Moving Images / Sam Kula. – Paris : UNESCO, 1983. – 130 p.
16. Schellenberg T. R. Principles of archival appraisal / Theodore R. Schellenberg // Modern Archives Administration and Records Management. – Pаris : UNESCO, 1985. – P. 269–279.
17. Stapleton R. The ideas of T. R. Schellenberg on the Appraisal, Arrangement, and Description of Archives / Rick Stapleton. – Ottawa : National Library of Canada, 1986. – 80 p.
18. Widła T. Interdyscyplinarność wspólczesnej ekspertyzy dokumentów / Tadeusz Widła, Marek Leśniak // Chowanna. – 2011. – № 2. – S. 279–298.
19. Boguslavskiy M. M. Kulturnyye tsennosti v mezhdunarodnom oborote : pravovyye aspekty : monogr. / M. M. Boguslavskiy. – 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. – Moskva : Norma : INFRA-M, 2012. – 416 s.
20. Domantcevych N. І. Osnovy ekspertyzy kulturnykh tsіnnostey : navch. posіb. / N. І. Domantsevich, M. N. Koval, A. P. Zakusіlov. – Lvіv : Lvіv. komertc. akad., 2011. – 240 s.
21. Kalashnikova O. L. Іdentifіkatsіya ta vartіsna otsіnka kulturnykh tsіnnostey : navch. posіb. / O. L. Kalashnikova. – Kyyiv : Vishcha shk., 2006. – 287 s.
22. Neshataeva V. O. Kulturnyye tsennosti : tsena i pravo / V. O. Neshataeva ; Natc. issled. un-t «Vysshaia shkola ekonomiki». – Moskva : Izd. dom Vyssh. shk. ekonomiki, 2013. – 208 s.
23. GOST R 7.087-2018 Sistema standartov po informatciyi, bibliotechnomu i izdatelskomu delu. Knizhnyye pamyatniki. Obshchiye trebovaniya [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://allgosts.ru/01/140/gost_r_7.0.87-2018. – Zagl. s ekrana.
24. Dokumentalnyye pamyatniki : vyyavleniye, uchot, ispolzovaniye : ucheb. posobiye / I. A. Altman [i dr.] ; pod red. S. O. Shmidta. – Moskva : Vyssh. shk., 1988. – 253 s.
25. Kovalchuk G. I. Knyzhkovi pamyatky (ridkisni ta tsinni knyzhky) v bibliotechnykh fondakh / G. I. Kovalchuk ; Nac. b-ka Ukrayiny im. V. I. Vernadskogo. – Kyyiv : NBUV, 2004. – 644 s.
26. Losiyevskiy I. Ya. Fond dokumentarnykh pamyatnikov v nauchnoy biblioteke : puti rasshireniya i predely innovatciy / I. Ia. Losiyevskiy // Nauch. i tekhn. b-ki. – 2020. – № 6. – S. 31–48.
27. Losiyevskyy I. Ya. Dokumentni pamyatky v bibliotechnykh zibrannyakh : teoretyko-metodolog. aspekty ta suchasna praktyka / I. Ya. Losiyevskyy // Visn. Khark. derzh. akad. kultury : zb. nauk. pr. – Vyp. 41. – Kharkiv, 2013. – S. 124–134.
28. Stolyarov Iu. N. Razvitiye dokumentologicheskoy terminologii / Iu. N. Stolyarov // Nauch. i tekhn. inform. – 2004. – Ser. 1. – № 8. – S. 5–10.
29. DSTU 4331:2004 Pravila opysuvannya arkhіvnykh dokumentіv. – Chin. vіd 17.08.2004. – Kyyiv : Derzhspozhyvstandart Ukrayiny, 2005. – ІV, 16 s. – Te z samo [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: http://imt.kpi.ua/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/DSTU_4331_2004.pdf.
30. Kabіnet Mіnіstrіv Ukrayiny. Postanova vіd 26 serp. 2003 r. № 1343 Pro zatverdzhennya Poryadku provedennya derzhavnoi ekspertyzy kulturnykh tsіnnostei ta rozmіrіv platy za ii provedennia [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1343-2003-%D0%BF. – Nazva z ekranu.
31. Losiyevskyy І. Ya. Derzhavna ekspertyza kulturnykh tsіnnostei : aktualnі problemy reglamentuvannya ta praktyky / І. Ya. Losіyevskyy // Vіsn. Khark. derzh. akad. kultury. – Vip. 25. – Kharkіv, 2009. – S. 26–31.
32. Mіnіsterstvo kultury Ukrayiny. Nakaz vіd 31.03.2017 № 267 Pro zatverdzhennya Perelіku derzhavnykh ustanov, zakladіv kultury, іnshykh organіzatsіy, yakym nadaietsya pravo provedennya derzhavnoyi ekspertyzy kulturnykh tsіnnostey [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0529-17. – Nazva z ekranu.
33. Kabіnet Mіnіstrіv Ukrayiny. Postanova vіd 12 serpnya 1992 r. № 466 Pro zatverdzhennya Polozhennya pro Derzhavnyy reyiestr natsіonalnogo kulturnogo nadbannya [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/466-92-%D0%BF. – Nazva z ekranu.
34. Mіnіsterstvo kultury і mystetctv Ukrayiny. Nakaz vіd 22.04.2002 № 258 Pro zatverdzhennya Іnstruktsіyi pro poryadok oformlennya prava na vyvezennya, tymchasove vyvezennya kulturnykh tsіnnostey ta kontroliu za yikh peremіshchennyam cherez derzhavnyy kordon Ukrayiny [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0571-02. – Nazva z ekranu.
35. Mіnіsterstvo kultury Ukrayiny. Nakaz vіd 06.10.2017 № 1005 Pro zatverdzhennya Polozhennya pro Ekspertno-fondovu radu z pytan bezoplatnoyi peredachі vyluchenykh abo konfіskovanykh kulturnykh tsіnnostey, obernenykh vіdpovіdno do zakonu v dokhіd derzhavy [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z1332-17. – Nazva z ekranu.
36. Mіnіsterstvo kultury Ukrayiny. Nakaz vіd 14.06.2016 № 437 Pro zatverdzhennia Іnstruktsіyi pro poryadok vіdboru rukopysnykh knyg, rіdkіsnykh і tsіnnykh vydan z bіblіotechnykh fondіv do Derzhavnogo reyiestru natsіonalnogo kulturnogo nadbannya [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon1.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0936-16. – Nazva z ekranu.
37. DSTU 2732:2004 Dіlovodstvo i arkhіvna sprava. Termіny ta vyznachennya ponyat. – Chin. vіd 01.07.2005. – Kyyiv : Derzhspozhyvstandart Ukrayiny, 2005. – ІV, 32 s. – Te z samo [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://vn.court.gov.ua/userfiles/27_2732-2004(1).pdf.
38. Kabіnet Mіnіstrіv Ukrayiny. Postanova vіd 8 serpnya 2007 r. № 1004 Pro provedennya ekspertyzy tsіnnostі dokumentіv [Elektronnii resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1004-2007-%D0%BF. – Nazva z ekranu.
39. Derzhavnyy komіtet arkhіvіv Ukrayiny. Nakaz vid 19.02.2008 № 34 Pro zatverdzhennya Metodyky vіdnesennya dokumentіv Natsіonalnogo arkhіvnogo fondu do unіkalnykh [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0202-08. – Nazva z ekranu.
40. Ekspertyza tsіnnostі dokumentіv // Pravyla roboty arkhіvnykh ustanov Ukrayiny / M-vo Yustytsіi Ukrainy, Derzh. arkh. sluzhba Ukrayiny, Ukr.nauk.-doslіd. іn-t arkh. spravy ta dokumentoznavstva ; uporyad.: L. A. Kiseliova [ta іn.]. – Kyyiv, 2013. – Gl. 2. – S. 15–23.
41. Іndutnyy V. V. Otsіnka kulturnykh tsіnnostey : pіdruch. / V. V. Іndutnyy. – Kyiv : KNTEU, 2016. – 880 s.
42. Kabіnet Mіnіstrіv Ukrayiny. Postanova vіd 13 grudnya 2004 r. № 1649 Pro zatverdzhennya Poryadku provedennya groshovoyi otsіnky dokumentіv Natsіonalnogo arkhіvnogo fondu [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1649-2004-%D0%BF. – Nazva z ekranu.
43. Derzhavnyy komіtet arkhіvіv Ukrayiny. Fond derzhavnogo mayna Ukrayiny. Nakaz 28.03.2005 № 34/683 Pro zatverdzhennya Metodyky groshovoyi otsіnky dokumentіv Natsіonalnogo arkhіvnogo fondu [Elektronnyy resurs]. – URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0692-05. – Nazva z ekranu.
44. Kovalchuk G. I. Expertyza knyzhkovyh pamyatok u bibliotekach : ukrayinoznavchyy aspekt // Ukrayina : kulturna spadshchina, natsіonalna svіdomіst, derzhavnіst. – Vyp. 21: Scripta manent. Iuvіleinyy zb. na poshanu Bogdana Iakymovycha. – Lvіv, 2012. – S. 403–416.
45. Losiyevskyy І. Ya. Etychnі ta psykhologіchnі osoblyvostі dokumentoznavchoyi ekspertnoyi dіialnostі / І. Ya. Losіievskyy // Korolenkіvskі chytannya 2015. «Bіblіoteky, arkhіvy, muzei : іnnovatsіinі modelі rozvytku» : materіaly XVIII mіzhnar. nauk.-prakt. konf. (m. Kharkіv, 8 zhovt. 2015 r.) : u 2 ch. / Kharkіv. derzh. nauk. b-ka іm. V. G. Korolenka, Kharkіv. derzh. akad. kultury, Khark. obl. vіd-nia VGO «Ukr. bіbl. asots.». – Kharkіv, 2016. – Ch. 2. – S. 87–100.
46. Ekspertyza dokumentalnykh pamyatok : robocha programa dlya studentіv spetsіalnostі 7.020105 «Dokumentoznavstvo ta іnformatsyyna dіyalnіst» / Derzh. akad. ker. kadrіv kultury і mystetctv; uklad. G. І. Kovalchuk. – Kyyiv, 2009. – 23 s.
47. Ekspertyza rіdkіsnykh knyg : robocha programa navchalnoyi distsyplіny / Kyyivskiy natsіonalnyy unіversytet kultury і mystetstv, fakultet іnf. polіtyky і kіberbezpeky, kaf. muzeieznavstva ta ekspertyzy іstoryko-kulturnykh tsіnnostey ; rozrobnyk G. І. Kovalchuk. – Kyyiv : KNUKіM, 2019. – 27 s.
48. Ekspertyza tsіnnostі dokumentnyh pamyatok : progr. ta navch.-metod. materіaly do kursu / Kharkіv. derzh. akad. kultury, Kharkіv. derzh. nauk. b-ka іm. V. G. Korolenka ; avt.-uklad. І. Ya. Losiyevskyy. – Kharkіv : Saga, 2013. – 310 s.
49. Kalinina-Simonchuk Yu. S. Ekspertyza tsinnosti rukopisnoyi ta knyzhkovoyi spadshczyny v zakonodavstvi Ukrayiny: suchasnyy stan ta perspektyvy rozvytku // Rukopysna ta knyzhkova spadshczyna Ukrayiny : arheografichni doslidzhennya unikalnyh arhivnyh ta bibliotechnyh fondiv / Nac. Akad. nauk Ukrayiny; Nac. b-ka Ukrayiny im. V. I. Vernadskogo, In-t rukopysu. – Vyp. 24. – Kyyiv, 2019. – S. 268–280.
Review
For citations:
Losiyevsky I.Ya. Appraisal of documentary heritage objects value in scientific library, archives, museum: topical problems of theory and practice. Scientific and Technical Libraries. 2021;(4):93-116. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.33186/1027-3689-2021-4-93-116
Views:
967
Email this article 