The concept and criteria for quality evaluation for printed books
https://doi.org/10.33186/1027-3689-2026-3-133-152
Abstract
Evaluation of the quality of printed book has been relevant to every subject in the book market, in particular, readers and library collection developers. The situation in the Russian book publishing market and technological revolution have aggravated the negative trends in accessibility of socially important publications, in particular, the sci-tech literature which circulation has been continuously decreasing. The authors introduce the concept of multistage evaluation of editing prepress preparation, design and graphic art quality, which enables relevant assessment of sci-tech book publications and, on the whole, socially important publications. Among the criteria are: system integrity of form and content, i. e. author’s work, its apparatus, art graphic, illustration, design and their conformity with intended end-use and targeted reader audience.
About the Authors
Konstantin M. SukhorukovRussian Federation
Konstantin M. Sukhorukov – Cand. Sc. (History), Editor-in-Chief, Bibliography and Bibliology Journal; Leading Researcher,
Moscow.
Svetlana A. Karaychentseva
Russian Federation
Svetlana A. Karaychentseva – Cand. Sc. (Philology), Chief Expert, Center for the Study of Libraries in Information Society,
Moscow.
Elizaveta M. Sukhorukova
Russian Federation
Elizaveta M. Sukhorukova – Cand. Sc. (Philology), Associate Professor,
Moscow
References
1. Бочарова Е. Н. Kriterii otbora dokumentov v fond nauchnoi` biblioteki // Vzaimovliianie informatcionno-bibliotechnoi` sredy` i obshchestvenny`kh nauk : sb. st. / RAN, INION, Fundament. b-ka; nauch. red. L. N. Tihonova, A. A. Dzhigo. Moskva : INION RAN, 2018. S. 62–78.
2. Evstigneeva G. A. O kriteriiakh komplektovaniia traditcionnogo bibliotechnogo fonda i fonda e`lektronny`kh publikatcii` v edinoi` sisteme formirovaniia bibliotechno-informatcionnogo fonda biblioteki na primere GPNTB Rossii // Nauchny`e i tekhnicheskie biblioteki. 2010. № 10. S. 23–29.
3. Kochukova E. V., Seliutckaia O. V. Osobennosti komplektovaniia nauchnoi` biblioteki v sovremenny`kh usloviiakh // Nauchny`e i tekhnicheskie biblioteki. 2016. № 8. S. 36–43.
4. Sokolova I. S. Estestvenno-nauchnaia kniga kak kommunikativnaia sistema : monografiia. Moskva : MGUP, 2008. 314 s. (Izdatel`skoe delo i zhurnalistika).
5. Mil`chin A. E`., Chel`tcova L. K. Spravochnik izdatelia i avtora: redaktcionno-izdatel`skoe oformlenie izdaniia. 7-e izd. Moskva : Izd-vo Studii Artemiia Lebedeva, 2024. 1008 s.
6. Sokolova I. S. Izdaniia po estestvenny`m naukam: sovremenny`e strategii podgotovki i vy`puska : monografiia. Moskva : MGUP, 2009. 144 s. (Izdatel`skoe delo i zhurnalistika).
7. Suhorukov K. M. Rossii`skoe knigovedenie, knizhnoe delo i gosudarstvo // Vzaimovliianie informatcionno-bibliotechnoi` sredy` i obshchestvenny`kh nauk : sb. materialov nauch. seminara / RAN, INION, Fundament. b-ka ; nauch. red. L. N. Tihonova, A. A. Dzhigo. Moskva : INION RAN, 2021. Vy`p. 4. S. 156–168.
8. Suhorukov K. M. Informatcionnaia kul`tura, knigovedenie i sovremennoe knizhnoe delo: vzaimosviazi i transformatcii // Bibliografiia i knigovedenie. 2022. № 1. S. 45–56.
9. Suhorukov K. M. Rossii`skaia pechatnaia kniga, knizhnaia i bibliograficheskaia kul`tura na sovremennom e`tape // Bibliografiia i knigovedenie. 2022. № 2. S. 85–110.
10. Nogina E. B., Antipov K. V. Kniga, chitatel`, knizhnaia torgovlia // Bibliografiia i knigovedenie. 2020. № 2. S. 65–75.
11. Suhorukov K. M. Spravochno-informatcionnoe li normativnoe obespechenie moskovskogo knizhnogo dela: problemy` i resheniia. Moskva : Rossii`skaia knizhnaia palata, 2005. 136 s.
12. Suhorukov K. M. Biblioteki i knizhnoe delo v Rossii: problemy` i perspektivy` vzaimodei`stviia // Bibliografiia i knigovedenie. 2022. № 4. S. 61–79.
13. Suhorukov K. M. Izdatel`sko-bibliograficheskoe oformlenie sovremennoi` knizhnoi` produktcii // Kniga. Issledovaniia i materialy`. 2011. Sb. 94. Ch. 1. S. 39–47.
14. Kalinin S. Iu. Vy`hodny`e svedeniia i spravochno-bibliograficheskii` apparat izdaniia : posobie dlia izdatelia. 6-e izd., pererab. Moskva : Rossii`skaia knizhnaia palata, 2016. 232 s. (Biblioteka Rossii`skoi` knizhnoi` palaty` : metodicheskie materialy` i rekomendatcii / nauch. red. serii K. M. Suhorukov ; vy`p. 12).
15. Frolov V. V. Rossii`skaia estestvennonauchnaia i tekhnicheskaia kniga : monografiia. Moskva : MGUP, 2008. 245 s. (Izdatel`skoe delo i zhurnalistika).
16. Perova G. V., Suhorukov K. M. Statistika rossii`skogo knigoizdaniia pervoi` poloviny` 2024 goda // Bibliografiia i knigovedenie. 2024. № 5. S. 39–41.
17. Suhorukov K. M. Gosudarstvennaia podderzhka rossii`skikh izdatelei` i pisatelei`: novy`e podhody` // Bibliografiia i knigovedenie. 2024. № 3. S. 29–39.
Review
For citations:
Sukhorukov K.M., Karaychentseva S.A., Sukhorukova E.M. The concept and criteria for quality evaluation for printed books. Scientific and Technical Libraries. 2026;(3):133-152. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.33186/1027-3689-2026-3-133-152
JATS XML































