Methodological case of scientometric factors study in individual discipline
https://doi.org/10.33186/1027-3689-2021-11-115-130
Abstract
The authors analyze scientometric factors and rates of the Russianlanguage scientific journals in archeology provided by RSCI. The list of journals under study was based on the list of peer-reviewed journals comprising findings of candidate’s and doctor’s theses in the domain 07.00.06 – Archeology (historical sciences). The key factors of these journals were specified and rates were made for Science Index (SI), public evaluation, and 5-year impact-factor. The journals with high impact factor and low SI rating were revealed; absolute discrepancy of 2019 SI and public evaluation rating. The authors suggest to make changes to the methods of calculating SI integrated index of scientific journals: to accumulate ratings and add special equalizing coefficients for monodisciplines: to calculate factors with improved rubricator.
About the Authors
R. R. Mukhametshin
A. Kh. Khalikov Institute of Archaeology of Tatarstan Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Ramis R. Mukhametshin – Head,
Department of Information and Editorial
Work
Kazan
K. M. Abdullin
A. Kh. Khalikov Institute of Archaeology of Tatarstan Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Khalim M. Abdullin – Cand. Sc. (History),
Senior Researcher
Kazan
References
1. Metodika rascheta integralnogo pokazatelya nauchnogo zhurnala v reytinge Science Index [Elektronnyy resurs] // Nauch. elektron. b-ka elibrary.ru. – URL: http://elibrary.ru/help_title_rating.asp (data obrashcheniya: 21.10.2020).
2. Voronin A. A. Kakaya effektivnost nuzhna rossiyskoy nauke // Sb. tr. Spets. vyp. 44. – Naukometriya i ekspertiza v upravlenii naukoy / pod red. D. A. Novikova, A. I. Orlova, P. Yu. Chebotareva. – Moskva : IPU RAN, 2013. – S. 56–66.
3. Tretyakova O. V. Reyting nauchnyh zhurnalov ekonomicheskih institutov RAN // Ekonom. i sots. peremeny: fakty, tendentsii, prognoz. – 2015. – № 5. – C. 159–172.
4. Chebotarev P. Yu. Naukometriya: kak s ee pomoshchyu lechit, a ne kalechit? // Sb. tr. Spets. vyp. 44. – Naukometriya i ekspertiza v upravlenii naukoy / pod red. D. A. Novikova, A. I. Orlova, P. Yu. Chebotareva. – Moskva : IPU RAN, 2013. – S. 14–29.
5. Larsson S. The third science revolution and its possible consequences in archaeology: A personal reflection // Current Swedish Archaeology. – 2014. – № 22. – C. 53–56.
6. Avdonin V. S., Meleshkina E. Yu. Politicheskaya nauka v zhurnalah: analiz instrumentov i pokazateley v informatsionnyh sistemah // Polit. nauka. – 2020. – № 1. – C. 87–111.
7. Avdonin V. S., Meleshkina E. Yu. O chem govoryat reytingi? Zhurnaly po politicheskoy nauke v sisteme RINTS // Polis. Polit. issled. – 2019. – № 4. – S. 69–88.
8. Lavrik O. L., Pleshakova M. A. Zhurnaly po problemam bibliotekovedeniya i bibliografovedeniya: mnogoaspektnyy naukometricheskiy analiz // Nauch. i tehn. b-ki. – 2016. – № 12. – S. 44–58.
9. Devisilov V. A. Reytingi rossiyskih nauchnyh zhurnalov, spetsializiruyushchihsya na problemah bezopasnosti, zashchity okruzhayushchey sredy i ekologii / V. A. Devisilov // Bezopasnost v tehnosfere. – 2014. – T. 3. – № 1. – S. 77–82. – doi: 10.12737/2783.
10. Demidov D. D. Nauchnye selskohozyaystvennye zhurnaly: bibliometricheskiy analiz po impakt-faktoru / D. D. Demidov // APK: Ekonomika, upravlenie. – 2014. – № 3. – S. 90–93.
11. Demidov D. D., Chavykin Yu. I. Otsenka zhurnalov po bibliotechnoinformatsionnoy deyatelnosti na osnove altmetricheskih pokazateley / D . D . Demidov, Yu. I. Chavykin // Nauch. i tehn. b-ki. – 2020. – № 11. – S. 59–72. – doi: 10.331186/1027-3689-2020-11-59-72.
12. Sokolova Yu. V., Borgoyakova K. S. Issledovanie rossiyskih otraslevyh nauchnyh zhurnalov (na primere fiziki) / Yu. V. Sokolova, K. S. Borgoyakova // Tam zhe. – S. 89–104. – doi: 10.33186/1027-3689-2020-11-89-104.
13. Muhametshin R. R., Asylgaraeva G. Sh. «Povolzhskaya arheologiya»: analiz naukometricheskih pokazateley zhurnala / R. R. Muhametshin, G. Sh. Asylgaraeva // Tam zhe. – 2021. – № 4. – S. 44–58. – doi: 10.331186/1027-3689-2021-4-44-58
14. Mazov N. A., Gureev V. N. Mesto zhurnalov Russian Science Citation Index v reytingovom spiske zhurnalov RINTS // B-ki i inform. resursy v sovrem. mire nauki, kultury, obrazovaniya i biznesa: 24-ya Mezhdunar. konf. «Crimea» (3–11.06.2017, g. Sudak : tr. konf.). – Moskva : Izdatelstvo GPNTB Rossii, 2017. – C. 1–6.
15. Busygina T. V. Altmetriya kak kompleks novyh instrumentov dlya otsenki produktov nauchnoy deyatelnosti // Idei i idealy. – 2016. – № 2 (28). – C. 79–87.
16. Kolledzh L., James K. «Korzina metrik» – luchshee sredstvo dlya otsenki avtoriteta zhurnala // Nauch. red. i izdatel / Science Editor and Publisher. – 2016. – № 1 (1–4). – S. 25–31.
17. Kotsofana T. V., Stazhkova P. S. Sravnitelnyy analiz primeneniya pokazateley kontsentratsii na primere bankovskogo sektora RF // Vestn. SPbGU. Ser. 5. – 2011. – Vyp. 4. – S. 30–40.
18. Bocharov S. G., Sitdikov A. G., Asylgaraeva G. Sh. Obshchie svedeniya o nauchnoy deyatelnosti Instituta arheologii im. A. H. Halikova Akademii nauk Tatarstana v 2019 godu // Povolzh. arheologiya. – 2020. – № 1. – S. 197–216.
19. Sitdikov A. G., Bazarov B. A., Gombozhapov A. D., Nolev E. V., Krasilnikov P. V. IV Mezhdunarodnyy kongress srednevekovoy arheologii evraziyskih stepey // Tam zhe. – S. 217–226.
20. Yavorskaya L. V., Bocharov S. G. Mezhdistsiplinarnyy nauchnyy seminar s mezhdunarodnym uchastiem «Arheobiologicheskie issledovaniya v Bolgare i na poseleniyah Zolotoy Ordy: problemy i perspektivy». 10–14 aprelya 2019 g., g. Bolgar (Spasskiy r-n, Respublika Tatarstan) // Tam zhe. – 2019. – № 2. – S. 237–242.
21. Sitdikov A. G., Botalov S. G., Izmaylov I. L., Krasilnikov P. V. Nauchnaya konferentsiya «IV Mezhdunarodnyy Madyarskiy Simpozium» // Tam zhe. – 2018. – № 4. – S. 324–333.
22. Galimova M. Sh. Yubiley Marii Alexanderovny Ochir-Goryaevoy // Tam zhe. – 2019. – № 3 (29). – S. 222–227.
23. Huzin F. Sh. K 90-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya A. H. Halikova (1929–2019) // Tam zhe. – № 2 (28). – S. 8–16.
24. Baranov V. S. K 50-letiyu sozdaniya Bolgarskogo gosudarstvennogo istorikoarhitekturnogo muzeya-zapovednika // Tam zhe. – S. 189–201.
25. Chizhevskiy A. A., Antipina E. E., Asylgaraeva G. Sh., Nuretdinova A. R. Kollektsii Arheologicheskogo muzeya Kazanskogo (Privolzhskogo) federalnogo universiteta // Tam zhe. – № 1. – S. 84–103.
Review
For citations:
Mukhametshin R.R., Abdullin K.M. Methodological case of scientometric factors study in individual discipline. Scientific and Technical Libraries. 2021;(11):115-130. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.33186/1027-3689-2021-11-115-130
Views:
566
Email this article 